Shop Online

Hand-waxed cheddar cheese aged from 6 months to 6 years. Unique and award-winning flavors to satisfy all cheese connoisseurs.

Famous cheese tarts, whoopie pies, shoo fly pies, and more. All freshly baked on site.

Mustards, jams, salsas, butters, honey, dressings and sauces

A fantastic assortment of crackers and snacks to complement your cheese.

John F. Martin meats and locally produced items from Stoltzfus Smoked Meats.

T-shirts, hats, cutting boards and other September Farm items.

Our gift assortments complement any celebration and are a special way to say "Thank-you" or "I care."

Cookbooks, plus attractive items for serving our cheeses and condiments