Shop Online

Cheeses

Hand-waxed cheddar cheese aged from 6 months to 6 years. Unique and award-winning flavors to satisfy all cheese connoisseurs.

Bakery

Famous cheese tarts, whoopie pies, shoo fly pies, and more. All freshly baked on site.

Farm Market

Mustards, jams, salsas, butters, honey, dressings and sauces

Crackers and Party Snacks

A fantastic assortment of crackers and snacks to complement your cheese.

Smoked Meats

John F. Martin meats and locally produced items from Stoltzfus Smoked Meats.

Logo Items

T-shirts, hats, cutting boards and other September Farm items.

Gifts

Our gift assortments complement any celebration and are a special way to say "Thank-you" or "I care."

For the Kitchen

Cookbooks, plus attractive items for serving our cheeses and condiments