Cheese Gifts For 2020 Holidays Season

Cheese Gifts

Find the perfect gift for your clients, employee, or loved ones. We will package and ship your gift directly to their door.

Shop Now

Cheese Curds

Enjoy cheese curds carefully crafted in our vat at September Farm Cheese. Choose between eight amazing flavors to satisfy your tastebuds.

Shop Now

Gift With Cheese Curds

Popular Cheeses

Shop for your favorite specialty cheese in our online store and have it arrive at your door.

Beware, there are many choices and many flavors to keep coming back over and over again.


Life is gouda when you are eating our Gouda cheese!

Jakes Aged Gouda Cheese
Shop Gouda


One, three, and ten year aged cheddar cheese and more.

Cheddar Cheese Aged
Shop Cheddar

Monterey Jack

Enjoy the flavor of our Monetry Jack in several flavors!

Shop Monterey

Swiss Cheese

Choose from our variety of scrumptious Swiss Cheeses.

Smoked Swiss Cheese Online
Shop Swiss

As Seen on the Food Network

A Day of Making Cheese with Chelsea White of the Food Network

Dave Rotelle, owner, and creator of September Farm never would have dreamed 13 years ago, while perfecting his first 2 pounds of fresh mozzarella in his home kitchen, that his cheese would eventually star on the famous FOOD NETWORK.

“Will Work for Food” is a thrilling cooking adventure show directed by FOOD NETWORK Kitchen starring famous Instagram Cake Baker and Decorator Chelsea White (@Chelsweets) who stopped by September Farm for a cheese creating lesson! Chelsea also sampled the town’s renown, homemade cheese!

Read the Whole Story

Your Source for Groceries

Shop in our store in Honey Brook, PA or order online and we will have your order ready for pickup.

September Farm Cheese

Your One Stop Destination near Lancaster County

september farm store

Country Store

Your One Stop Shop.

There is nothing like actually watching the the process of cheese becoming cheese. At September Farm you can experience shopping for fine cheeses, Lancaster County baked goods and and tasting on the location where our cheese is made. Take home a basket of local foods: cheese, meats, quiche, salads, frozen foods, fresh produce and more.

See the Store Order Groceries

Sandwich Shop

But actually more than that!

Famous for our toasted cheese sandwiches made a dozen different ways, on homemade bread with plenty of September Farm cheese. Amazing sandwiches, homemade soups, mac and cheese, hoagies, wraps, fried cheese curds and a whole lot more.

Visit our Sandwich Shop
grilled ham cheese sandwich
making cheese on the food network at september farm cheese

Cheese Factory

Watch the actual process.

While shopping in our country market and sipping on your freshly brewed latte, you can watch the cheese making process first hand.

Visit September Farm

Ice Cream and Coffee Coop

A hot pick for a cool destination.

Enjoy hand dipped ice cream, our own homemade ice cream, gourmet coffee drinks or yogurt smoothies made with our own fresh yogurt.

Visit our Coffee Coop

About September Farm in Chester County, PA

The September Farm Story

It began in our kitchen… when my husband Dave Rotelle decided to try his hand at making cheese for the first time. This idea wasn’t just a Saturday afternoon activity. The idea was spurred after visiting cheese makers in New England while on a family trip. A dream was about to become reality. With a basic cheese-making kit and recipe in hand, he produced the first small wheel of cheese in our farmhouse kitchen. It was the first step in the realization of his dream to pursue a family business where we could work together and build a business that our children may one day call their own.

Watch the September Farm Story

Meet the Rotelle Family

September Farm is owned and operated by David and Roberta Rotelle, extending the Rotelle family name in the food industry to a fourth generation. Roberta and David are personally committed to producing the highest-quality dairy products.

Meet the Rotelle Family

Our Cheese Has Been Featured on…

Keep in touch with September Farm

Get weekly updates on new products, in-store and online discounts, and what’s happening at September Farm.