Cheeses

Below you will find all flavors of cheese made at September Farm available for online purchase.

September Farm Aged Gouda
Authentic Dutch-Style Gouda aged to perfection in our cheese cave. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
September Farm Baby Gouda
This traditional Dutch-style baby Gouda is a pleasantly young cheese. Approximately  8 oz.
$6.92
Honey Brook Mild Cheddar
Handwaxed and aged approximately three months. Creamy, mild, and distinctively farm fresh.
$4.99
Honey Brook Medium Cheddar
Handwaxed and aged approximately six months. Creamy with notes of cheddar sharpness.
$4.99
Handwaxed and aged approximately one year. One of the most popular cheeses we sell. 
$4.99
Honey Brook Smoked Cheddar
This cheese is especially for cheese lovers who like it smoked.
$4.99
Pizza Jack
Light spice and pepperoni are added to this cheese along with hints of onion and red pepper.
$4.99
Aged Swiss
$5.15
Bacon Smoked Cheddar
Our smoked cheddar with the addition of bacon.
$4.99
Garlic and Basil Jack
This cheese is a perfect compliment to Italian dishes and makes a nice melt for meatball subs.
$4.99
Chili Pepper Cheddar
Chili Pepper Cheddar is aged with chili peppers then rolled in extra peppers before packing.
$5.75
Habanero Jack 8 oz
The addition of habanero pepper makes this cheese super hot!
$4.99
Smoked Jalapeno Jack
The unique combination of smokey flavor and jalapeno peppers make this cheese a special treat.
$4.99
Spring Onion Jack 8 oz
A lovely blend of chives and onion add delicate flavor to Spring Onion Jack.
$4.99
Muffaletta Cheddar
This distinctive cheese is made with a blend of olives, garlic, and olive oil.
$4.99
Honey Brook Jack
Taste the freshness in this delicious, mild Monterey Jack cheese!
$4.99
 Maple Smoked Gouda
This cheese is smoked in-house and is always a customer favorite. Approximately   8 oz.
$7.49
Super hot and sweet. This cheese has some fire!
$4.99
Handwaxed and aged approximately two years.
$5.75
Chives & Dill Jack
This cheese is an award winner at the American Cheese Society and the Pa. Cheesemaker's Competition
$5.25
Horseradish Cheddar
In this cheese, we use fresh horse radish for a distinct, fresh taste.
$4.99
Harvest Jack
This cheese will delight you with a unique blend of herb and vegetable flavors.
$4.99
A light addition of cranberry and orange zest make this cheese a holiday star! 
$5.25
Joy's Tomato Basil Jack
Sun-dried tomato and basil flavor this cheese bearing the name of the owner's mother and daughter.
$4.99
Jumpin' Jack Jalapeno
Jalapenos make this fresh, creamy cheese a customer favorite.
$4.99
Dusted in chipotle cheddar before packing, this is our cheesemaker's favorite cheese!
$5.75
Very distinctive, this yellow cheddar adds color and sharpness to any dish.
$7.29
Super sharp, this cheese is an amazing treat for cheddar lovers.
$8.29
Salsa Jack
Laced with the flavors of onion, peppers, and tomatoes, this cheese compliments Mexican dishes. 
$4.99
Apple Cinnamon Cheddar
 Perfect for the fall and holidays, this cheese has the taste of apple pie and cheddar cheese.
$5.75
Pepperoni Augusto Jack
With pizza ingredients like pepperoni and oregano, this is our most popular Monterey Jack cheese.
$5.25
Cracked Black Pepper Gouda
Baby Gouda blended with the perfect amount of fresh, cracked black-pepper. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
Original Cheese Curds
8 oz.
$4.99
Horseradish Bacon Cheddar
This cheese combines the flavor of fresh horseradish with bits of bacon.
$7.29
Cave Aged Cheddar 8 oz
Premium cheddar aged in our cave under perfect conditions. Creamy and sharp.
$6.89
Bacon Horseradish Cheese Curds
8 oz. (turkey bacon)
$4.99
Wheel of Baby Gouda
Treat yourself to a handcrafted, classic wheel of Gouda. Each wheel is approximately 2 lb. 
$23.98
Cheese Spread
Available in-store only from May-September Delicious soft cheese spreads that will "wow" your...
Muffaletta Gouda
Blended olives and a hint of garlic flavor this authentic muffaletta cheese. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
pepper-jack
The flavors of jalapeno and red pepper blend perfectly in this zesty cheese.
$7.99
Selected by the owners, this cheese is cave-aged to perfection and available in limited quantity.
$9.50
Cajun Cheese Curds
8 oz.
$5.29
Subscribe to receive three cheeses each month
Join our Cheese of the Month Club to receive a monthly shipment of three cheeses. Each package will...
$115
Cumin Gouda
Savory cumin makes this the most popular flavored Gouda in Holland. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
Maple Smoked Cheddar
Authentic maple cheddar naturally cold smoked at September Farm.
$5.75
Nettle Blend Gouda
Nettle has many health benefits and blends with other subtle herbs in this cheese.
$7.49
smoked-swiss
$5.15
Bacon Smoked Cheese Curds
8 oz. (turkey bacon)
$4.99
September Farm Baby Swiss
$5.15
Garlic Dill Cheese Curds
8 oz. 
$4.99
Blue Cheese
Approximately 5-7oz.
$4.59

Bite-sized pieces of cheddar cheese right from our vat

Available in-store during summer season. Please check back in the fall for product availability on website.

Amish Butter Cheese, Swiss, Farmer's Cheese, Mozzarella and More