Cheeses

Bite-sized pieces of cheddar cheese right from our vat

Amish Butter Cheese, Swiss, Farmer's Cheese, Mozzarella and More

Below you will find all flavors of cheese made at September Farm available for online purchase.

September Farm Aged Gouda
Authentic Dutch-Style Gouda aged to perfection in our cheese cave. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
September Farm Baby Gouda
This traditional Dutch-style baby Gouda is a pleasantly young cheese. Approximately  8 oz.
$6.92
Honey Brook Mild Cheddar
Handwaxed and aged approximately three months. Creamy, mild, and distinctively farm fresh.
$4.99
Honey Brook Medium Cheddar
Handwaxed and aged approximately six months. Creamy with notes of cheddar sharpness.
$4.99
Handwaxed and aged approximately one year. One of the most popular cheeses we sell. 
$4.99
Honey Brook Smoked Cheddar
This cheese is especially for cheese lovers who like it smoked.
$4.99
Pizza Jack
Light spice and pepperoni are added to this cheese along with hints of onion and red pepper.
$4.99
Aged Swiss
$5.15
Bacon Smoked Cheddar
Our smoked cheddar with the addition of bacon.
$4.99
Garlic and Basil Jack
This cheese is a perfect compliment to Italian dishes and makes a nice melt for meatball subs.
$4.99
Chili Pepper Cheddar
Chili Pepper Cheddar is aged with chili peppers then rolled in extra peppers before packing.
$5.75
Habanero Jack 8 oz
The addition of habanero pepper makes this cheese super hot!
$4.99
Smoked Jalapeno Jack
The unique combination of smokey flavor and jalapeno peppers make this cheese a special treat.
$4.99
Spring Onion Jack 8 oz
A lovely blend of chives and onion add delicate flavor to Spring Onion Jack.
$4.99
Muffaletta Cheddar
This distinctive cheese is made with a blend of olives, garlic, and olive oil.
$4.99
Honey Brook Jack
Taste the freshness in this delicious, mild Monterey Jack cheese!
$4.99
 Maple Smoked Gouda
This cheese is smoked in-house and is always a customer favorite. Approximately   8 oz.
$7.49
Super hot and sweet. This cheese has some fire!
$4.99
Handwaxed and aged approximately two years.
$5.75
Chives & Dill Jack
This cheese is an award winner at the American Cheese Society and the Pa. Cheesemaker's Competition
$5.25
Horseradish Cheddar
In this cheese, we use fresh horse radish for a distinct, fresh taste.
$4.99
Harvest Jack
This cheese will delight you with a unique blend of herb and vegetable flavors.
$4.99
A light addition of cranberry and orange zest make this cheese a holiday star! 
$5.25
Joy's Tomato Basil Jack
Sun-dried tomato and basil flavor this cheese bearing the name of the owner's mother and daughter.
$4.99
Jumpin' Jack Jalapeno
Jalapenos make this fresh, creamy cheese a customer favorite.
$4.99
Dusted in chipotle cheddar before packing, this is our cheesemaker's favorite cheese!
$5.75
Very distinctive, this yellow cheddar adds color and sharpness to any dish.
$7.29
Super sharp, this cheese is an amazing treat for cheddar lovers.
$8.29
Salsa Jack
Laced with the flavors of onion, peppers, and tomatoes, this cheese compliments Mexican dishes. 
$4.99
Apple Cinnamon Cheddar
 Perfect for the fall and holidays, this cheese has the taste of apple pie and cheddar cheese.
$5.75
Pepperoni Augusto Jack
With pizza ingredients like pepperoni and oregano, this is our most popular Monterey Jack cheese.
$5.25
Cracked Black Pepper Gouda
Baby Gouda blended with the perfect amount of fresh, cracked black-pepper. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
Original Cheese Curds
8 oz.
$4.99
Horseradish Bacon Cheddar
This cheese combines the flavor of fresh horseradish with bits of bacon.
$7.29
Cave Aged Cheddar 8 oz
Premium cheddar aged in our cave under perfect conditions. Creamy and sharp.
$6.89
Bacon Horseradish Cheese Curds
8 oz. (turkey bacon)
$4.99
Wheel of Baby Gouda
Treat yourself to a handcrafted, classic wheel of Gouda. Each wheel is approximately 2 lb. 
$23.98
Cheese Spread
Delicious soft cheese spreads that will "wow" your tastebuds and your guests! These are perfect for...
$5.29
Muffaletta Gouda
Blended olives and a hint of garlic flavor this authentic muffaletta cheese. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
pepper-jack
The flavors of jalapeno and red pepper blend perfectly in this zesty cheese.
$7.99
Selected by the owners, this cheese is cave-aged to perfection and available in limited quantity.
$9.50
Cajun Cheese Curds
8 oz.
$5.29
Subscribe to receive three cheeses each month
Join our Cheese of the Month Club to receive a monthly shipment of three cheeses. Each package will...
$99
Cumin Gouda
Savory cumin makes this the most popular flavored Gouda in Holland. Approximately  8 oz.
$7.49
Maple Smoked Cheddar
Authentic maple cheddar naturally cold smoked at September Farm.
$5.75
Nettle Blend Gouda
Nettle has many health benefits and blends with other subtle herbs in this cheese.
$7.49
smoked-swiss
$5.15
Bacon Smoked Cheese Curds
8 oz. (turkey bacon)
$4.99
September Farm Baby Swiss
$5.15
Garlic Dill Cheese Curds
8 oz. 
$4.99
Blue Cheese
Approximately 5-7oz.
$4.59