Cheese is a timeless go to thank-you gift. It’s the perfect “food gift” that’s practical, yet thoughtful. While Velveeta and American cheese might be refrigerator staples; quality, farm fresh, beautifully packaged blocks of cheese are usually not.

When September Farm started making cheese in their kitchen back in 2007, it took them little time to realize that the product itself was the best form of advertising. When the Rotelle family set off in their camper for a family vacation, the camper fridge was well stocked with all their favorite bars of cheese. They handed out bars of cheese to all the kind people they met along the way. Campground staff, fellow campers . . . it soon became clear that September Farm cheese was a wonderful way to say “thank you.” Perhaps it was for this reason that so much care and attention was put into the hand waxed bars, colorful, with artistic labels and creative and unique flavor combinations.

Short on time or creativity? The team at September Farm has done the hard work for you in curating beautiful baskets and sampler boxes combining cheese with delicious accompaniments ranging from Lancaster County meats, mustards, and pretzels, to homemade baked goods, and handmade cutting boards.

Pretzels & Cheese Gift

The Pretzels & Cheese gift has been a favorite of customers for years. The combination of pretzels and cheese is a Lancaster County staple, and this gift gives you the opportunity to share not only three bars of your choice of September Farm handcrafted cheese, but also hand rolled, Lancaster County hard pretzels, and a jar of sweet honey mustard.

Send a Snack Lover's Gift

Mouse & Cheese Gift

The Mouse & Cheese gift packs a lot of punch. Although it is one of our smallest gift options, it is unique and special with a bar of cheese and our popular “cheese wire” sitting atop a handcrafted mouse shaped cutting board (adorable!) personalized with our September Farm.

Send a Keepsake Gift

Cheese: A Classy Way to Say Thank You

Years ago I was driving alone from a wedding ceremony to the reception when I failed to yield to the oncoming traffic in a major intersection. The result was a head-on collision with a bright blue pickup truck and we sat in the middle of the intersection while the wedding guests all filed past. I tried to keep myself pulled together despite the whiplash, humiliation, and trauma, but I was in tears. Several minutes went by when a middle aged couple from the wedding—mere acquaintances—kindly stopped to give support and oversight. They acted as “mom and dad,” helping me exchange insurance information and answer questions by the police.

I was so blessed by their kindness that day, I felt overwhelmed by a desire to bless them in return. How does one thank “the Good Samaritan”? My choice: a thoughtful thank you note and a small sampler box from September Farm Cheese.

Joy Rotelle

Farm Favorites Gift Basket

If you want to say “thank you” in a BIG way, you can’t go wrong with the Farm Favorites gift options. These gifts include a beautiful assortment of September Farm favorites all packed inside a September Farm cooler bag.

Send a Premium Gift Basket

Our Cheese Has Been Featured on…

a girl reading a note with cheese

Make a statement that’s anything but cheesy.

Amplify your gift with a personalized message. Every gift message is printed on high-quality stationary and carefully packaged inside your box of goodies.

Specify your gift message at checkout.

Send Your Gift

The Big Cheeses: Our Premium Gift Packages

Something to Remember You By: Keepsake Gift Included

Beyond Cheese: Sweet and Salty Little Nothings

Who Doesn’t Love Cheese: Snack-Lovers Cravings

Thinking of You: A Cheese-themed Kindness Token

Variety Packs: A Bit of Cheese for Everyone

Put Some Cheese in The Game.

If you prefer the do-it-yourself route, you can have the fun of shopping the selection either in store or online and creating a one of a kind gift of your own. All of our products provide a one-of-a-kind opportunity: from our farm to your friend!

Create A Custom Gift