A Cheese Gift for Every Occasion

Shipping all over the USA

Friends and Family

It’s not only during the holiday season that we give gifts. Celebrate a graduation, a birthday or an anniversary with a cheese gift basket. 

Client Gifts

Give the gift of cheese to show appreciation to your clients in 2023. Get discounts when you spend $500+ holiday orders. 

Employee Gifts

Show appreciation to employees with a meat and cheese gift basket that can also include Uncle Henry’s Pretzels and other goodies paired to compliment the cheese.

Popular Cheese Gift Baskets

Shop for your favorite specialty cheese in our online store and have it arrive at your door. But beware: there are many choices and many flavors. You’ll keep coming back over, and over, and over, and over….

Small Sampler

This is a low cost small basket that features some of our greatest cheeses made right here on the farm. 

Learn More

Pretzel’s And Cheese

3 bars of cheese with locally handmade Uncle Henry’s Pretzels and sweet dipping mustard.

Learn More

Large Sampler

Pick 4 of our special cheeses that you would like to try along with some other great goodies on the side!

Learn More

Farm Favorites Deluxe

This popular cheese gift contains an outstanding selection of locally made foods!

Learn More

Choose a Cheese Gift

4.7777777777778 out of 5
a girl reading a note with cheese

Your Personalized Message

Make A Statement That’s Anything But Cheesy Amplify your gift with a personalized message. Every gift message is printed on high-quality stationary and carefully packaged inside your box of goodies.

Specify your gift message at checkout.

Shop All Gifts

our cheese has been featured on...

More Meat, Cheese and Cracker options

We have many more choices in our collection of meats, cheeses and other categories that would serve as great gifts at any time of the year. Simply choose the cheese flavors you want and we’ll pack it up and ship to for any important occasion. 

A few of our Favorites

Meat and Cheese Gift Boxes

Anyone would be delighted with the September Farm Favorites Deluxe cheese gift box that also includes Lancaster County meat. Add to that a box of crackers and some old fashioned Uncle Henry’s Pretzels with sweet mustard to top it off and you’ll have a gift that will set well to the taste buds and communicate the appreciation you wish to share. 

Buy this Gift


The Pretzels & Cheese gift has been a favorite of customers for years. The combination of pretzels and cheese is a Lancaster County staple, and this gift gives you the opportunity to share not only three bars of your choice of September Farm handcrafted cheese, but also hand rolled, Lancaster County hard pretzels, and a jar of sweet honey mustard.

Buy this Gift

about september farm

Cheese Gifts from the Heart

Made in Pennsylvania

At September Farm, we know that gifts you give speak of appreciation, love and care and you want to share that through the language of a unique cheee gift. From ourch cheese vat to your friends, family, employees or clients, we strive to help you communicate through the gift of cheese.

Find Your Gift

The September Farm and Rotelle Family story

September Farm is owned and operated by David and Roberta Rotelle, extending the Rotelle family name in the food industry to a fourth generation. Roberta and David are personally committed to producing the highest-quality dairy products.

Our Cheese Speaks

Cheese Basket was Great!

My son and daughter-in-law were so very pleased with the gift basket of cheeses, pretzels and mustard. One bag of the Martin’s pretzels and mustard was enjoyed very quickly. My son is a avid pretzel fan and said they were the best he’s ever eaten. The second bag of pretzels and the cheeses were enjoyed by out of town guests they were hosting, and all gave rave reviews. Was deliciously enjoyed by the out of town guests they were hosting. The basket was lovely, and arrived incredibly fast. Thank you so much. I will certainly be ordering other gift baskets in the future. – Yvonne B.

Loved it!

I bought this package for for my friends, They absolutely loved it. You guys are definitely good at what you do. Thank you so much – Stuart A


cheese gifts

the perfect “food gift” that's practical, yet thoughtful

Cheese is a timeless go-to thank-you gift. While Velveeta and American cheese might be refrigerator staples, quality, farm-fresh, beautifully packaged blocks of cheese are usually not.

When September Farm started making cheese in their kitchen back in 2007, it took them little time to realize that the product itself was the best form of advertising. When the Rotelle family set off in their camper for a family vacation, the camper fridge was well stocked with all their favorite bars of cheese. They handed out bars of cheese to all the kind people they met along the way. Campground staff, fellow campers . . . it soon became clear that September Farm cheese was a wonderful way to say “thank you.” Perhaps it was for this reason that so much care and attention was put into the hand waxed bars, colorful, with artistic labels and creative and unique flavor combinations.

Short on time or creativity? The team at September Farm has done the hard work for you in curating beautiful baskets and sampler boxes combining cheese with delicious accompaniments ranging from Lancaster County meats, mustards, and pretzels, to homemade baked goods, and handmade cutting boards. Choose a sampler of fresh cheese curds made in our PA cheese making facility. Find the perfect gift for your clients, employees, or loved ones. We will package and ship your gift directly to their door.

shop all gifts

keep in touch with september farm

Get updates on new products, online discounts, and what’s happening at September Farm.